Sunday, June 5, 2022

Proposals for the Expedited Amendment for the Constitution for Revitalizing Sovereignty of the people and for a Stable Government

 

Proposals for the Expedited Amendment for the Constitution for Revitalizing Sovereignty of the people and for a Stable Government

 

The proposed constitutional amendment shall aim at, completely depoliticization of the governing system through establishing /revitalizing the following commissions with wider powers, to deal with political interference from any level of hierarchy – i.e., all these commission shall be of totally independent of interferences and have powers to deal with those interfering and or hindering, through judicial process,    

1.     The Election Commission, The Public Service Commission, The Audit Service Commission, The Human Rights Commission of Sri Lanka, The Finance Commission, The Delimitation Commission, The National Procurement Commission, The University Grants Commission

2.     The Parliament shall assume the Executive power, and the Executive Presidential system be abolished with immediate effect, whereas, the Prime Minister, as the head of the Government and the Cabinet of Ministers is accountable to Parliament.

3.     Parliament shall establish the Constitutional Council and appoint the chairmen, secretaries and the members in a prudent manner for the independent commissions above mentioned in 1- other than Judicial Service Commission

4.     The Constitutional Council members and its activities will be similar to that of found in 19th Amendment of 2015, but except for  

a.      President will not appoint a member, instead the parliament will appoint two members, as described below

b.      Two persons nominated by agreement of the majority of the Members of Parliament belonging to political parties or independent groups, other than the respective political parties or independent groups to which the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition belong.

c.      Four persons appointed by The Speaker, The Prime Minister, The Leader of the Opposition, and  from State recognized Professional bodies, who may or may not be a Parliament Member and include fifth person the Chairman of the National Judicial Service Commission (described below 5) who will be the Chief Justice as well, and in turn who would have been approved by the Constitutional Council itself.  

d.      The Constitutional Council will not appoint Attorney General, The Chairman for the National Police Commission (NPC) and to The Commission to Investigate Allegations of Bribery or Corruption (CIABC)   

 

5.     *Though The Judicial Service Commission will continue as an independent professional body, shall be elevated as The National Judicial Service Commission (NJSC) and be further strengthened and established to bring the Attorney General’s (AG) Department, The National Police Commission (NPC), The Commission to Investigate Allegations of Bribery or Corruption (CIABC) and The Criminal Investigation Department (CID) under its purview in order to be free of the menace meddling by drug king-pins, wealthy criminals, selfish politicians etc. As such the respective chairpersons of The NPC and The CIABC and the CID shall be appointed by The NJSC itself to begin with. Law enforcement should be independently handled by Department of Police headed by Inspector General Police who is answerable and responsible only to NPC, AG and hence to The NJSC and to the entire Judiciary system. IGP shall be appointed by the NJSC on the recommendation of the NPC within the purview of NJSC shall handle the all the transfers required for the optimum effectiveness of the law enforcement by the Police Department. As such Ministry of Law and Order shall be incorporated into the Ministry of Justice.

The objectives of this proposal are to prevent governing system affiliating to any political party either ruling or non-ruling or opposition, impartiality of the law enforcement ensuring the Sovereignty of the People and continuity of dispensing justice even on change of government - and to prevent judicial jurisdiction being encroached by political greediness and political whims of revenge on each other.

 

6.     An additional independent Commission be established, by the Constitutional Council of Parliament for Poverty Alleviation (NPAC) and its activities shall be decentralized provincially, The National Poverty Alleviation Commission will monitor the progress of the poverty alleviation in respect of number and progress of self-reliance, number of participants to be reduced each year for each province. The NPAC also involve Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) and monitor the activities of the NGOs in a wider spectrum.     

 

7.     The Constitutional Council shall as well under take the,

 

        I.          the appointments of the Governor of the Central Bank of Sri Lanka and the Monetary Board should also be done with the approval of the Constitutional Council;

      II.           The appointments of the Secretaries to the Ministries, Governors, Ambassadors and Heads of Missions to be done on the advice of the Prime Minister in consultation with the Cabinet of Ministers;

     III.          Selecting the Presidential Candidate through Parliament, once the amendment is enacted.

 

   

8.     The Department of Archaeology should be brought under and supervised by another Independent Commission for Diversified Cultural Heritage, in order to appropriately preserve and interpret artifacts found beyond of 2600 years, and to prevent the Department of Archeology being influenced by prejudiced, short-sighted politicians and religious groups interfering for political gains, which has been the case since independence. The Constitutional Council shall ensure such commission is established with members representing of Experts of History from all ethnicity.

      

9.     The President shall be only of ceremonial and decorative and shall be the Chief of Tri-Forces and be elected by the Parliament, shall not hold any cabinet portfolios. The exception is that, current president will be functioning as Minister of Defense until his first term ends, unless he resigns before the end of term.   

 

10.  Once the amendment is enacted in Parliament, incumbent president, unless he resigns, shall continue until the end of his first term, shall not affiliate himself to any political party.  

 

11.  President on completion of the 1st term of 5 years, Parliament will hold the discretion to reelect the incumbent president, or to elect a new president on the recommendations of the religious leaders of any sect and societies of all religions and any other civic societies compulsorily not affiliating to any political party. The Constitutional Council of Parliament will scrutinize the recommendations forwarded by the civics through key performance Index and political affiliation. Simple majority in the parliament enable the select to the Highest Office, if two or more candidates selected by PCC as suitable,  

 

12.  Any candidate for presidential office selected by Parliament Constitutional Council to be elected by the Parliament, found to be canvassing among the Parliament members for disqualifies automatically to be in the contest or to hold the Presidential office.

 

13.  A non-Citizen or a Dual Citizen can neither hold nor be appointed to any office within Sri Lanka, nor be allowed to represent Sri Lanka outside Sri Lanka

 

14.  Any elected body or any person shall not entertain a request for Pardoning of convicts, pardoning shall only by process done by National Judicial Service Commission, on the recommendation by Parliamentary Constitutional Council.  

 

15.   Department of Prisons and the Commissioner general of Prisons, as well shall come under the purview of National Judicial Service Commission, in the context of there have been numerous occasions Commissioner General of Prisons and the prisoners have been used for Political vandalism at the disposal of politically starved politicians.  

 

16.   a. Rescind the Special Presidential Commission of Inquiry appointed by Gazette (Extraordinary) No. 2212/53 of 29 January 2021 to implement the recommendations and decisions made by the Presidential Commission of Inquiry appointed to Investigate Allegations of Political Victimization during the Period Commencing 8 January 2015 and ending 16 November 2019 appointed by Gazette (Extraordinary) No. 2157/44 of 9 January 2020. 

  b. Refrain from implementing the recommendations of the Presidential Commission of Inquiry appointed to Investigate Allegations of Political Victimization during the Period Commencing 8 January 2015 and ending 16 November 2019 appointed by Gazette (Extraordinary) No. 2157/44 of 9 January 2020.

 

The objectives of these above proposals for the expedited amendment for the constitution is to create a Stable Government that reflects the ability to reform towards, transparency, impartiality in law enforcement free of individual interferences and discretions, as credibility to negotiate with the IMF, other multilateral agencies, and friendly countries to help Sri Lanka get out of the economic crisis, which is also help to achieve the following in the ground situation

 

            1. To create political, economic and social stability in the country.

2. To create an environment to address the fundamental problems that have brought about the current crisis (and imperil the future reforms).

3. To restructure external debt and enter into appropriate programs with multi-lateral institutions including the IMF and for that purpose to appoint the financial and legal advisers and negotiate a debt standstill pending debt restructuring.

4. To obtain bridging finance. The bridging finance together with the savings arising from the debt standstill to be used to procure uninterrupted supply of essentials to the People until such time the debt restructuring, and the IMF program is in place. This will eliminate the shortages in power, fuel, gas, medicines, food, etc.

5. To create an environment to combat corruption and to ensure accountability and strengthening independent institutions. 

Electorally Revitalizing the Sovereignty of the People


1.     The New Electoral Process should be Based on 2004 Parliament Select Committee Headed by Hon. Dinesh Gunawardene on Electoral Process.


2.     70% should be absolutely on First Past the Post System, (FPPS) that enables the voter to clearly identify the candidate through the ballot paper itself rather than by just numbers. The voter clearly identifying the candidate is an important part of the universal franchise, in which the voter clearly, sum up the candidate’s suitability as a persona to represent the voter to an Electorate. This should never be considered as preference voting instead voters’ discretion with conviction in which the voter is given a broad opportunity to elect a correct person as the voter marks the ballot paper just by one mark only. Since there is never a practice of one vote for a party and second marking for a candidate of another party an elective candidate should not hide behind the numbers, a hallmark of franchise system and appropriate way to abolish the Preference Voting where marking up to 3 are allowed. If the candidature is honest and bold there is no need for candidates to hide behind the numbers.


3.     The above described absolute FPPS allows an individual to field his candidature on his own without relying on a political party or a group, and seek a membership in a local council / parliament to serve her/his own electorate people, in which likes of Dahanayakes, Mudiyanse Thennako

nes, Navaratnams, Sunthralingams and some Islamic members have emerged and had done yeoman service got their opportunities through the system to serve their own people in the era before 1977. This is another characteristic of the Universal Franchise, in which people of an electorate electing their own individual woman/man had been deprived of by the present system and I understand in the proposed system as well. This must be corrected in the proposed new sew system. The inability of an individual being field herself/himself as candidate for councils have paved way forming of undesired groups and sprouting of numerous short-sighted political parties. 70% FPPS won’t hinder Independence Groups fielding their candidate in an election.


4.    The Balance 30% of members of a councils/ Parliament should be derived from vote casted for a political party through a candidate of that political party or an Independence Group, which makes the mixed electoral process simple and smart, easy to understand by the voter, - most important factor in seeking public mandate. Political parties will hand over two applications one for individual candidate representing that political party in a particular electorate and list of names that will represent the party in the council or in the Parliament for the balance 30%, and such 30% list should be properly advertised enabling the voter to decide on a political party or on the individual the party fielded as a candidate or on an Independence Candidate.  

5.     The characteristics of a franchise system should not be compromised for the bad/criminal activities of politically oriented supporters at all cost, or for the cost of Electoral Franchise.

6.     Such a system of 30% members deriving allow the political parties and independence groups to elect most demanding women representation and professional experts to municipal councils and Parliament. It also can be effectively used for justifiably elect members from minorities of an area or of an electoral district.

7. This kind of Mixed Electoral System (MES) becomes best effective in reflecting the choice of the people, when total number of members of a local government body is considered as basic unit and for Provincial Council and in Parliament Election number of members carried by an Electoral District becomes basic unit. Though for Provincial council and Parliament total number of members can be considered as basic unit, it is not recommended as it will deprive or limit the appropriate representation of different ethnic groups. E.g. if Jaffna Municipal Council carries 40 members, 28 members will be elected through wards wise FPPS and 12 will be derived through Proportional Representation System (PRS).  In a Parliament election If Jaffna Electoral District carries 10 members 7 electorates will elect seven members through FPPS, the balance 3 will be allocated to political parties mustering over 7.5 % of the total valid votes cast of the electoral district/local council for gaining representation. All electoral Districts having less than 7 members for Parliament should be duly adjusted through provincial basis to attain  appropriate the (70:30)% Electoral Mixed Representation.

 

 8.    Merit for Qualification.


 There was a proposal to have a floating number of members to Parliament, Provincial councils, and local councils to accommodate all those contesters attaining stipulated percentage of total valid votes.  This shouldn’t be the case; all elected governing bodies must have fixed numbers to be elected and there should be merit system to accommodate the best only to attain the fixed number of members that has been already stipulated among  qualified- all those who attained more than 7.5% of the total valid votes for the electoral district or for the Local government; this 7.5% can be further  reduced to if this merit system is introduced for the benefit of  minor political  parties and Independence Groups.


A Merit Value of MES qualification (Q) for membership system can be easily derived by calculating the distance of deviation from average polled to attain membership, against the Total Valid votes polled amongst all who attained 7.5%.  E.g.   
In a Parliament Election if Colombo Electoral District carries 20 members, total valid votes polled is divided by 20 to arrive at average votes needed to attain the one member.  If it is the value of 35000 (X) and If a qualified Party A has polled 8000it needed 27000 (Ad), more votes to qualify. If another Party B has polled 8950 B party requires 26050 (Bd)more votes to qualify which is 950 votes less than Party A required.  Therefore, obviously Party B will have to qualify than Party A.
 This is presented here as a formula to obtain a Merit Value of MES qualification by finding the percentage distance against the Total Valid votes Cast(Z) for the Electoral District.


Likewise, a merit list can be prepared for queuing up qualified political parties and least Q value parties are disqualified one by one to accommodate the best polled parties in the 30% allocation seats. Such merit list can be used to arrive at stipulated number of winners for all elected governing and administrative bodies.

 9. The List of Names handed over to accommodate the 30% proportional representation before the voting process to any governing bodies or parliament, should not be allowed to altered whatsoever after the particular election is completed, so that the any candidate for 70% FPPS who has been rejected by the electors by voting, shall not gain membership to any ruling body or Parliament.         

10. A Neutral office of the President who is not affiliating to any political party, encage with Election Commission and with National Judicial Service omission (NJSC) to monitor political parties and its’ members, next president elect nominee and executing the election laws for and during an election process, the office shall not assume ministerial powers or any other power vested in her /him once the proposed amendment has been enacted.

 

11. The ruling political party shall not initiate or implement any projects using the government coffers within the 12 months of next election.

 

12. If a person of Sri Lankan origin who had dispelled the citizenship of another country is still ineligible to contest an election, or hold any office, unless she/he has lived in Sri Lanka and has disconnected the affairs with any foreign country for the last five years of election.

 

13. A Parliament Member elected or nominated through a political party disqualifies to continue as a Parliament Member when crossover to another political party.

 

 

1.     14. The Parliament Members, since they are elected by the people to represent the people and as the parliament membership is not a profession, should not be entitled for any pension scheme, irrespective of they represent the people for five or more than five years.

 

2.     The salaries of the MPs shall be stipulated and recommended by a State Salary Commission according to their educational qualification and their sitting to sittings contributions.

 

3.     All healthcare facilities currently provided to any politicians should be abolished, except the health facilities that are relevant to the general public.

 

 

4.     The free transport, electricity, water and phone facilities they are currently entitled to should be abolished.

 

5.     Every parliamentarian who has been charged with crimes, criminal charges, imprisoned or sentenced should be removed from his position and banned from re-election forever. The inappropriate financial accumulation they have attained should be charged from themselves, their family members and from representatives.

 

 

6.     The MPs who have not declared their assets, even after 3 months of swearing in as MP shall be disqualified as Member of Parliament.

7.     Every parliament member/minister should be subservient to the laws and rules applicable to the common citizens of the country.

 

8.     Neither a candidate nor a sitting MP who has not passed the G.C.E Advanced Level should be allowed to continue as a Member of Parliament.

 

9.     Food and all other relief privileges in the parliament should be abolished

 

10.  Age limit should be stipulated as below 60 years to enter Parliament in order to accommodate young and fresher views in the August Sabah

 

 

11.  a MP who possesses a certified expert knowledge in particular field, shall be appointed to the relevant subject as a minister.      

 

Parliament is an August Sabah, where service is an Honourable undertaking as a representative of the people and it is not a privilege to earn or right to steal people's money and property. People who elect the MPs deserved to be treated respectfully, no matter most of the people may hold different opinions of the MPs, since the younger generation and the people outside the Parliament are far more knowledgeable than within the Parliament.  

If these reforms proposal found to be require a referendum, despite the present crisis situation, there shall be a referendum at the earliest possible, that include broader aspects of the constitution, in addition to above proposals, both of which ensures sovereignty of the people entrusted to the people themselves directly in democratic governance as well; rather than by the elected executive and representatives both of which have changed course to autocratic rule after being elected in 2019 and 2020.